Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Talk about the other 3800 powered GM cars, particularly for items not covered in other sections that may be unique to your year/model, and differ from a Bonneville.
Post Reply
User avatar
harrydunn
Posts like an LN3
Posts like an LN3
Posts: 410
Joined: Thu May 22, 2008 8:40 am
Year and Trim: 2000 SE
Location: Columbia, MO

Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by harrydunn »

Hey guys--

Did't get any response on the GP forums so I thought I'd come home and post here. :wink: I'm confused on where to post--I like it here but don't have a Bonneville anymore!

Anyways, the new 2001 Grand Prix GTP Coupe (55K miles). If I accelerate normally, I feel a minor shudder on the 1-2 shift about 30% of the time. If I accelerate harder (nowhere near WOT however), no shudder and the shift is very positive. Fluid level is right on the money. I actually have a two-month engine/transmission warranty that will be up in 10 days so I figured I'd ask if it was anything major. I know a 9-year old car isn't going to be perfect.

Your thoughts? TCC? Motor mount?

Thanks!
Last edited by harrydunn on Wed Jun 10, 2009 9:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image

2001 GTP Coupe | Redfire Metallic | 55K Miles
1993 Toyota Land Cruiser FZJ80 | Pearl White
2000 Bonneville SE | Arctic White | 55K Miles | 18" GXP Rims | Cleared Corners | Debadged | Factory Spoiler Installation | Bosal Dual Exhaust Conversion | K&N | Annoying Shimmy! | SOLD

HANG UP AND DRIVE
petraman
Certified Bonneville Nut
Certified Bonneville Nut
Posts: 4343
Joined: Mon May 19, 2008 10:01 pm
Year and Trim: .
2013 Audi A4 6MT
Location: ............ Granville, Ohio/Erie, PA *WCBF '08 SURVIVOR* *NEBF '07 SURVIVOR*

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by petraman »

What kind of plug wires does it have? I know that my bad Taylor wires are causing that same issue right now...
2013 A4 P+ ------------------ Glacier White Metallic
6MT, Sport Pkg, JHM Stage 1 Clutch/LWFW, JHM Short Shifter, JHM HFC, USP SS Clutch Line, CR-15 Strut Bar, Alu Kreuz, BFI Shift Knob, EC Trans Mount Insert, VCDS tweaks.
User avatar
harrydunn
Posts like an LN3
Posts like an LN3
Posts: 410
Joined: Thu May 22, 2008 8:40 am
Year and Trim: 2000 SE
Location: Columbia, MO

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by harrydunn »

Original wires from '01. It sure doesn't feel like an engine miss. Definitely feels like it's transmission-related. Perhaps not?
Image

2001 GTP Coupe | Redfire Metallic | 55K Miles
1993 Toyota Land Cruiser FZJ80 | Pearl White
2000 Bonneville SE | Arctic White | 55K Miles | 18" GXP Rims | Cleared Corners | Debadged | Factory Spoiler Installation | Bosal Dual Exhaust Conversion | K&N | Annoying Shimmy! | SOLD

HANG UP AND DRIVE
00Beast
Retired Site Developer
Retired Site Developer
Posts: 20960
Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 10:30 pm
Year and Trim: '17 Silverado 1500
Location: MN/IA
Contact:

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by 00Beast »

Engine troubles can seem like tranny issues. Make sure everything on this list is up-to-date, and see if the troubles go away.

Brand Suggestions are in the parentheses.
  • 1987-2005 Bonneville / Buick 3800 Maintenance List

    Run Seafoam through gasoline and intake every 5,000 miles. One pint of Seafoam in a half tank of fuel is a good mix. The intake is optional, but recommended.

    Grease: Ball Joints, Tie Rods Every 8-10k ( recommended) [b]Air Filter[/b] [i]Every 15k[/i] [s ... Amsoil EaA, Purolator PureONE)[/size]
    PCV Valve Every 30k
    MAF Sensor Element Cleaning/TB Cleaning Every 50k viewtopic.php?f=48&t=1661
    Fuel Filter Every 15-25k (Purolator, AC Delco, WIX)
    Spark Plugs Every 30-50k (NGK TR55 or Autolite 605) (Never Bosch)
    Ignition Wires Every 30-50k (Napa Belden, AC Delco, Autolite Pro, NGK) (Never Taylor or Bosch)
    Oil & Filter Every 5-6k or Every 6 months (Mobil1 or Amsoil)(Mobil1, Purolator PureONE, Amsoil EaO or WIX) (Never Fram) viewtopic.php?f=45&t=214
    *Conventional Oil Every 3k/3 months(Pennzoil with a WIX (Napa), Delco or Purolator filter)
    Transmission Flush Every 15-20k (Always make sure filter is changed when flushed)
    Cooling System Flush Every 25-50k or Annually (Peak or Prestone Green Coolant Only) (Never Dexcool)
    Oxygen Sensor Every 80-100k (30k for non-heated) (AC Delco or Denso) (Absolutely never Bosch) viewtopic.php?f=48&t=794
    Accessory Belt Inspect every 15k, replace every 100k, or as needed
    Cabin Air Filter Inspect and Replace every 15k, or as needed in dusty conditions. (Note: 00+ Only)
    Evap Core Cleaning Whenever Needed (Note: 99 and older only) viewtopic.php?f=45&t=2432

    *Special Considerations*
    All 3800s, LG3, LN3, L27, L36, L26, L67 & L32, especially important on vehicles factory installed with orange Havoline Dexcool Antifreeze/Coolant: http://www.dex-cool.net/
    Lower Intake Manifold Gasket Replacement, every 80-100k (ignorance of this can allow coolant to enter your engine oil, this happening can cause irreversible lower engine damage, requiring replacement of subject engine)

    Series II, Naturally Aspirated, RPO:L36:
    Upper Intake Manifold Plenum Replacement, Every 80-100k (ignorance of this can allow coolant to enter your intake manifold, possible damage to occur can be hydrolock, irreversible damage to emissions devices, misfires, etc. Most times, engine replacement is required if ignored long enough.) viewtopic.php?f=53&t=1061

    Series I, II, III RPO Code L67 & L32:
    Change Supercharger Oil; Every 30-50k. (Intense Racing or GM Dealer) viewtopic.php?f=56&t=1690
    Supercharger Belt (Series II and III only); Inspect Every 15k, Replace Every 100k or as needed.

    Rev. 6/7/09 By 00Beast
Bye Bye:
Image
RIP sandrock
Sirius wrote:Think about it. You’re tooling down the road in your Prius, knowing full-well that this thing being green is as big a sham as federally mandated ethanol-enriched gas, Russia pulling out of Ukraine, and Obamacare.
User avatar
Archon
Resident Gearhead
Resident Gearhead
Posts: 8781
Joined: Mon May 19, 2008 10:30 pm
Year and Trim: 2014 Cadillac XTS Vsport.
Location: Grand Rapids, Michigan

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by Archon »

If the fluid hasn't been changed lately, try that first. These transmissions have a rather sloppy 1-2 shift to begin with, to try and make it less noticeable. Worn fluid could make it worse.
*Gone, but not forgotten* - Black 2000 SSEi, HIR Headlights, Angel Eyes fogs, 3rd brake light overlay, hi-flo cat, 180 degree thermostat, HS 1.9 rockers, LSx yellow springs, Intense FWI, PCM, shift kit, push rods, and 3.4 Pulley. ZZP Power Log.
User avatar
J Wikoff
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 17080
Joined: Mon May 19, 2008 7:01 pm
Year and Trim: 1992 SSE
2009 G8 GT
Location: Central Illinois
Contact:

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by J Wikoff »

I had something similar. I tried ruling out all the engine related shudders. Eventually the shudder got worse and worse until I either had to drive it hard or manually shift the lower gears to hold them longer to get above the range where it would shudder. I even tried a new vacuum modulator. The behavior changed but really didn't get any better. Suddenly one day it would barely go into gear. It was rebuild time.
Image
WHITE WHINE - 1992 SSE Supercharged 236.26 ci (.040 Over) 15.090 at 90.2 MPH on old engine w/ slipping trans & melted O2 sensor - Gen 3 M62 and matching TB, Gen 2 Pully, Zillamotorsports Ported LIM, YT 1.72 Roller Rockers, SII FPR & Injectors, Hypertech Thermomaster chip w/ 160 Thermo, TransGo Shift Kit, Infinity/Pioneer Speakers & a 10" Alpine Type R Sub, all the watts, 140 amp Alternator, Ricepipe CAI w/ heatshield, Pilot Angel Eye Foglights, Clear Corners, '02 17" Chrome Bent 5's, Magnaflow F-Body Muffler and Hi-flo Cat, Ceramic Coated Ported Exhaust Manifolds, Fan Override, Monroe Reflex struts, red calipers
2009 G8 GT - Sport Red Metallic, loaded, SOLO Axlebacks, Rotofab Intake, Tuned, autodim mirror, removed intake manifold cover, HSV GTS triple gauge pod, two tone red-hot shifter and HSV SuperSport steering wheel, GXP rear sway bar and diffuser, 3.45 diff and various Camaro suspension bits, LED Taillights
01bonneSC
Certified Bonneville Nut
Certified Bonneville Nut
Posts: 4938
Joined: Sat May 24, 2008 5:18 pm
Year and Trim: 05 Chevy 'Hoe
1997 'maro (3.8L M5)
89 SkiDoo
Location: Sycamore, IL

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by 01bonneSC »

PCS? TCC?
Image
00Beast wrote:Less off-topic than Lane's Heated Steering wheel, but yeah, back to the topic.
1fatcat
Posts like an L67
Posts like an L67
Posts: 1254
Joined: Mon Mar 30, 2009 11:18 pm
Year and Trim: before cars
Location: Zimmerman, MN

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by 1fatcat »

Thats a classic symptom of a failing pressure control solenoid. I have replaced a great deal of these solenoids for this very reason. One thing to check first is the mass air flow sensor. If it is dirty, it can effect shifting.

If shifting improves with a MAF cleaning, that does not mean the PCS is OK. It is probably still the weak link that made the problem noticable. After cleaning the MAF, the PCM may register more air flow and command the PCS to higher pressure. This will make the shifts firmer and mask a "first sign" failing PCS.

If you still have a warranty remaining, I would bring it to the dealer and tell them everything you told us and suggest that it may be a failing PCS "because you had a different pontiac that did that" and see what they say.

If they replace it, I would THEN clean the MAF sensor.
User avatar
harrydunn
Posts like an LN3
Posts like an LN3
Posts: 410
Joined: Thu May 22, 2008 8:40 am
Year and Trim: 2000 SE
Location: Columbia, MO

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by harrydunn »

***Also, another huge thing I forgot to mention. The transmission has a nice whine to it which from what I'm reading is PCS-related***

The car has been dropped off at my local Pontiac dealer. My concern is that it is so faint and doesn't happen all the time that they will dismiss the problem. I'm tuned into it and can sense it pretty easily. I made sure he wrote down possible failing PCS on the ticket for the mechanic to see, shudder on 1-2 shift, whine. The car has to be warm with light throttle applied to feel it. Heading up an incline helps as well.
Last edited by harrydunn on Thu Jun 11, 2009 9:45 am, edited 1 time in total.
Image

2001 GTP Coupe | Redfire Metallic | 55K Miles
1993 Toyota Land Cruiser FZJ80 | Pearl White
2000 Bonneville SE | Arctic White | 55K Miles | 18" GXP Rims | Cleared Corners | Debadged | Factory Spoiler Installation | Bosal Dual Exhaust Conversion | K&N | Annoying Shimmy! | SOLD

HANG UP AND DRIVE
User avatar
JBMark33
Posts like an L36
Posts like an L36
Posts: 840
Joined: Thu May 22, 2008 11:40 am
Year and Trim: 2000 SE
Location: NW PA

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by JBMark33 »

I was able to fix my PCS Issues by installing a mild shift kit :wink:

Half way down page 2 is where I installed my shift kit...
http://www.pontiacbonnevilleclub.com/fo ... 1&start=20
Last edited by JBMark33 on Thu Jun 11, 2009 10:28 am, edited 1 time in total.
Current: '12 Audi S4 Quattro Prestige 6MT

Previous: '06 Audi S4 Quattro 6MT (for sale!)
'06 Chevy Cobalt SS, Stage II: 2.0L Supercharged, 16psi boost, G85 Package; Recaro Racing Seats, Limited Slip Differential, 5 Speed Manual
'00 Pontiac Bonneville SE ( 4 years, 197,000 miles)
'99 Dodge Intrepid ES (1 year, 2 engines)
'95 Chevy Lumina (2 years, 164,000 miles)
1fatcat
Posts like an L67
Posts like an L67
Posts: 1254
Joined: Mon Mar 30, 2009 11:18 pm
Year and Trim: before cars
Location: Zimmerman, MN

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by 1fatcat »

Sounds good. Let us know what happens.
User avatar
harrydunn
Posts like an LN3
Posts like an LN3
Posts: 410
Joined: Thu May 22, 2008 8:40 am
Year and Trim: 2000 SE
Location: Columbia, MO

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by harrydunn »

Diagnosis:

#06-07-30-023B: 4T65E Transmission 1-2 Shift Shudder at Light to Moderate Acceleration (Replace Complete Second Clutch Assembly) - (Jan 12, 2007)

I've already contacted the dealer where I bought it with a warranty still intact but I have my doubts that they are going to own up and pay it. Very pricey.
Image

2001 GTP Coupe | Redfire Metallic | 55K Miles
1993 Toyota Land Cruiser FZJ80 | Pearl White
2000 Bonneville SE | Arctic White | 55K Miles | 18" GXP Rims | Cleared Corners | Debadged | Factory Spoiler Installation | Bosal Dual Exhaust Conversion | K&N | Annoying Shimmy! | SOLD

HANG UP AND DRIVE
User avatar
J Wikoff
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 17080
Joined: Mon May 19, 2008 7:01 pm
Year and Trim: 1992 SSE
2009 G8 GT
Location: Central Illinois
Contact:

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by J Wikoff »

Why wouldn't they pay?
Image
WHITE WHINE - 1992 SSE Supercharged 236.26 ci (.040 Over) 15.090 at 90.2 MPH on old engine w/ slipping trans & melted O2 sensor - Gen 3 M62 and matching TB, Gen 2 Pully, Zillamotorsports Ported LIM, YT 1.72 Roller Rockers, SII FPR & Injectors, Hypertech Thermomaster chip w/ 160 Thermo, TransGo Shift Kit, Infinity/Pioneer Speakers & a 10" Alpine Type R Sub, all the watts, 140 amp Alternator, Ricepipe CAI w/ heatshield, Pilot Angel Eye Foglights, Clear Corners, '02 17" Chrome Bent 5's, Magnaflow F-Body Muffler and Hi-flo Cat, Ceramic Coated Ported Exhaust Manifolds, Fan Override, Monroe Reflex struts, red calipers
2009 G8 GT - Sport Red Metallic, loaded, SOLO Axlebacks, Rotofab Intake, Tuned, autodim mirror, removed intake manifold cover, HSV GTS triple gauge pod, two tone red-hot shifter and HSV SuperSport steering wheel, GXP rear sway bar and diffuser, 3.45 diff and various Camaro suspension bits, LED Taillights
User avatar
harrydunn
Posts like an LN3
Posts like an LN3
Posts: 410
Joined: Thu May 22, 2008 8:40 am
Year and Trim: 2000 SE
Location: Columbia, MO

Re: Faint Shudder on 1-2 shift...

Post by harrydunn »

They have agreed to pay so I'm quite pleased. I can have the work done locally as well. They're only going to pay what they could do it for at their service shop but it's only a couple of hundred bucks cheaper so I'm more than happy to pay the difference instead of driving the car five hours for them to repair. It's refreshing to see a dealer willing to work with you to make things right instead of creating a huge hassle for you so you'll just drop the whole thing and forget about it. They've earned my repeat business. :wink:
Image

2001 GTP Coupe | Redfire Metallic | 55K Miles
1993 Toyota Land Cruiser FZJ80 | Pearl White
2000 Bonneville SE | Arctic White | 55K Miles | 18" GXP Rims | Cleared Corners | Debadged | Factory Spoiler Installation | Bosal Dual Exhaust Conversion | K&N | Annoying Shimmy! | SOLD

HANG UP AND DRIVE
Post Reply