EGR block-off

Talk about modifications, or anything else associated with performance enhancements. Have a new idea for performance/reliability? Post it here. No idea is stupid! (please use Detailing and Appearance for cosmetic ideas)
User avatar
willwren
Retired Admin
Retired Admin
Posts: 65489
Joined: Sun May 18, 2008 11:07 pm
Year and Trim: .
93 SSEi
95 SLE (SC)
97 Buick LeSabre
Location: Oregon WCBF'04, '05, '06, '07, '08, '09, '10, '11 Survivor
Contact:

Re: EGR block-off

Post by willwren »

Nexuscocker wrote:Sorry about the side note:

Is it for effective to port the inlet of a M90 rather than the outlet? Based off that data I would think that porting the inlet would lessen the heat that was created, but in not and engineer.
On the M90, don't PORT anything. You can improve efficiency by simply smoothing and polishing the inlet and outlet (replace the needle bearings afterwards) to get all the bumps and sharp edges out without enlarging either feature.

Paul (bullet), I know it doesn't make sense, and I've mulled it over ever since I ran the data and found the other data, but the data is what the data is. The only thing I can put a finger on is that the inlet is rather rough in stock cast form, and the air reaches a restriction in the inlet, and has to turn upwards to enter the compressor chamber at that point.
Image
Click here for mod list for both cars
93 SSEi, 95 SLE (supercharged) 97 Buick LeSabre Limited
PontiacDad at WCBF '04: Cruise control? That's like surrendering!
Comprehensive guide to troubleshooting, rebuilding, and modifying Eaton Superchargers
00Beast
Retired Site Developer
Retired Site Developer
Posts: 20960
Joined: Tue May 27, 2008 10:30 pm
Year and Trim: '17 Silverado 1500
Location: MN/IA
Contact:

Re: EGR block-off

Post by 00Beast »

Could it be friction of the air as it's being restricted through the TB and inlet?
Bye Bye:
Image
RIP sandrock
Sirius wrote:Think about it. You’re tooling down the road in your Prius, knowing full-well that this thing being green is as big a sham as federally mandated ethanol-enriched gas, Russia pulling out of Ukraine, and Obamacare.
User avatar
2000Silverbullet
Retired Gearhead
Retired Gearhead
Posts: 12225
Joined: Mon May 19, 2008 5:06 pm
Year and Trim: 2000 SSEi, 79 Firebird, 88 Jeep, 11 Yukon Denali
Location: Powell River BC - 7 time WCBF Survivor

Re: EGR block-off

Post by 2000Silverbullet »

Could it be the 500 F EGR ?

Before I removed it I couldn't hold my hand on the TB it was so hot.

Now with both EGR and coolant disconnected, it is cold. With no intercooler.

When your engine is warm try to grab that TB at the EGR entrance and feel for yourself.
All that heat will conduct into the casing and hence warm the air.
Image
2000 SSEi - SilverBullet - 78,000 kms, 4" "straight shot" custom headlight ram air inlet, TOGs, 1.9's, Lsd, 2.9-3.4"MPS 10-15 psi, Ported GenV, EGR eliminated, OR pushrods, oil volume kit, trani cooler & shift kit, Titanium retainers, 90 lb springs, 160 Stat, 42# injectors, Fuel pump voltage increase, Wideband O2, 3" to dual 2 1/2" Magnaflows, Snow Meth/water injection, after SC temp gauge, 255/50WR17, timing commander set 15-18*@WOT, 2 speed Fan over-ride, disabled DRL, Solid motor mount, Meziere Electric water pump, adjustable fuel pressure regulator, Drilled & slotted rotors/ceramics, GXP sway bars and STB, Upgraded and rebuilt transmission with ZZP 2500 rpm stall TC, Pioneer Bluetooth stereo with sub and 800 W amps, PB 13.5 quarter, (April 2014 car of the month)
User avatar
willwren
Retired Admin
Retired Admin
Posts: 65489
Joined: Sun May 18, 2008 11:07 pm
Year and Trim: .
93 SSEi
95 SLE (SC)
97 Buick LeSabre
Location: Oregon WCBF'04, '05, '06, '07, '08, '09, '10, '11 Survivor
Contact:

Re: EGR block-off

Post by willwren »

Paul, neither set of data I posted accounted for the EGR, and as I said before, my modeling showed a very minor effect from it.
Image
Click here for mod list for both cars
93 SSEi, 95 SLE (supercharged) 97 Buick LeSabre Limited
PontiacDad at WCBF '04: Cruise control? That's like surrendering!
Comprehensive guide to troubleshooting, rebuilding, and modifying Eaton Superchargers
xX3800Xx
SLE Member
SLE Member
Posts: 50
Joined: Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:19 pm
Year and Trim: 1990 Lesabre
1987 Lesabre

Re: EGR block-off

Post by xX3800Xx »

I was wondering if your modeling was only accounting for the effect of the EGR gas temp on the air temp in the intake or if it accounted for the heat soak in the charger where the EGR enters the air flow that would also heat up the air.
1fatcat
Posts like an L67
Posts like an L67
Posts: 1254
Joined: Mon Mar 30, 2009 11:18 pm
Year and Trim: before cars
Location: Zimmerman, MN

Re: EGR block-off

Post by 1fatcat »

It's the coolant that is making that thermal map hot at the inlet. Unless the laws of physics no longer apply in Minnesota, there is no way that the inlet temps are hotter than the compressed outlet temps of the air charge...NO WAY! I will bet my car on it!

What tools did you use, willwren, to collect this data?
User avatar
willwren
Retired Admin
Retired Admin
Posts: 65489
Joined: Sun May 18, 2008 11:07 pm
Year and Trim: .
93 SSEi
95 SLE (SC)
97 Buick LeSabre
Location: Oregon WCBF'04, '05, '06, '07, '08, '09, '10, '11 Survivor
Contact:

Re: EGR block-off

Post by willwren »

You last two posters missed two key points. It's not the coolant. That passage was set to coolant temp before the test was run in my model, and unaccounted for in the older model. I did not allow the coolant temp to rise above normal in the test. That heat came from elsewhere.

Neither my model (shown) nor the older model accounted for the EGR at all.

The old model shown (black and white) was made in CAD, and various known temperatures were constrained before the test.
2: Constraints

The bottom surface was constrained to 120° Celsius (250° Fahrenheit), the intake (the hole in the trapezoid) to 36° C/ 97° F, and the other surfaces exposed directly to the engine bay were set at 76° C/169° F. Surfaces exposed to the engine bay that shared an edge with the bottom mounting plate were left unconstrained.
I did the same, but with some differences. I made my own 3D model based on an empty housing, and constrained the bottom surface of the supercharger and the coolant passage to known temperatures off my cars when warmed up, then began the test with a typical CFM of air through the inlet.

My model was created in CoCreate Solid Modeling (hp designed it originally under UNIX as ME30, then sold it to CoCreate who now license it back to us as a discount under windows). I used the finite element analysis module for my thermal testing.

One possibility for the odd rise in temperature is that the lower area of the inlet isn't exposed to engine bay air. Their model was more simplified, causing the entire inlet to rise in termperature. My model was far more advanced, and showed a specific rise in one area.


I did my modelling quite some time ago, and don't recall the results of every test. I varied alot of the parameters including coolant on/off, coolant temp, LIM surface temp, air temp, etc. Every time, whether the EGR or Coolant was on or off, the lower surface of the inlet was always hot. In some tests, the outlet did rise in temp, until I smoothed off the edges in the model (which is why I port/smooth my inlet and outlet the way I do now).
Image
Click here for mod list for both cars
93 SSEi, 95 SLE (supercharged) 97 Buick LeSabre Limited
PontiacDad at WCBF '04: Cruise control? That's like surrendering!
Comprehensive guide to troubleshooting, rebuilding, and modifying Eaton Superchargers
User avatar
2000Silverbullet
Retired Gearhead
Retired Gearhead
Posts: 12225
Joined: Mon May 19, 2008 5:06 pm
Year and Trim: 2000 SSEi, 79 Firebird, 88 Jeep, 11 Yukon Denali
Location: Powell River BC - 7 time WCBF Survivor

Re: EGR block-off

Post by 2000Silverbullet »

Bill ported my Gen5 SC using his knowledge but I insisted on him filling my EGR hole with JB weld and I plugged the coolant ports in the LIM. :wink:

EGR block off works for me.

It's a personal choice.
Image
2000 SSEi - SilverBullet - 78,000 kms, 4" "straight shot" custom headlight ram air inlet, TOGs, 1.9's, Lsd, 2.9-3.4"MPS 10-15 psi, Ported GenV, EGR eliminated, OR pushrods, oil volume kit, trani cooler & shift kit, Titanium retainers, 90 lb springs, 160 Stat, 42# injectors, Fuel pump voltage increase, Wideband O2, 3" to dual 2 1/2" Magnaflows, Snow Meth/water injection, after SC temp gauge, 255/50WR17, timing commander set 15-18*@WOT, 2 speed Fan over-ride, disabled DRL, Solid motor mount, Meziere Electric water pump, adjustable fuel pressure regulator, Drilled & slotted rotors/ceramics, GXP sway bars and STB, Upgraded and rebuilt transmission with ZZP 2500 rpm stall TC, Pioneer Bluetooth stereo with sub and 800 W amps, PB 13.5 quarter, (April 2014 car of the month)
Post Reply